Warning: session_start() [function.session-start]: open(/home/content/74/5445474/tmp/sess_6lu3rtg6kn53l6ad99atda5rv0, O_RDWR) failed: No such file or directory (2) in /home/content/74/5445474/html/wordpress/wp-content/plugins/instagrate-to-wordpress/instagrate-to-wordpress.php on line 48

Warning: session_start() [function.session-start]: Cannot send session cookie - headers already sent by (output started at /home/content/74/5445474/html/wordpress/wp-content/plugins/instagrate-to-wordpress/instagrate-to-wordpress.php:48) in /home/content/74/5445474/html/wordpress/wp-content/plugins/instagrate-to-wordpress/instagrate-to-wordpress.php on line 48
My Favorite Budget Bourbons (and Ryes) | Ethan Prater
Skip to content

My Favorite Budget Bourbons (and Ryes)

Bourbon is hands down the best value to be found in whisk(e)y in the US today. Quality is high – very little of your grandfather’s rotgut can be found on contemporary shelves. And the prices, while rising far faster than inflation, can’t be beat – especially when compared to Scotch whiskies of similar quality.

Following are my favorite American whiskies that can be found for under $20 per 750ml bottle. Prices listed are current on the linked retailers’ web sites as of 15-December-2009. (By the way, WordPress’ thumbnail creator is cruel, chopping off lots of the images – if you click on them, you can browse the full labels and photos in all their glory.)

  • Jim Beam Black Label (bourbon, $16.99)

    Jim Beam Black is one of my favorite bourbons at any price. Vastly better than the standard white label stuff. Big and rich tasting, but relatively little alcohol burn given its quite assertive character. In fact I think this whiskey might be from the same batches used for Booker’s – another favorite of mine – though in this case they make sure it’s least eight years old (+), dilute it down to 86 proof (-) and filter it (-). So what? Jim Beam Black is not just good – it’s great.

  • Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond (rye, $19.99)

    The world has found out about this great whiskey bargain, so the producers and distributors have kicked up its price from $12 a few years ago to over $20 in some markets. Oh well – Rittenhouse Rye 100 proof Bottled in Bond is still the best rye for the money available today. And it’s a nice introduction to the style generally. Rittenhouse BIB showcases the unique spiciness and fruitiness of rye grain without becoming edgy like some of its competitors. Drinks beautifully on its own, but also makes a wonderful cocktail. (Be careful not to confuse this with the 80 proof Rittenhouse Rye, with the tan label. I’ve compared them only once, but much preferred the 100 proof version, which is worth the extra couple of bucks over its little brother.)

  • Very Old Barton Bottled in Bond (bourbon, $12.99)

    I love this hard-to-find bourbon so much that I wrote an entire blog post about it here. What are you waiting for? If Binny’s will ship to your state, call them up (or click on the price above) and have them send you a bottle. Even with shipping costs you’re still well under $20 to try this gem.

  • Elijah Craig 12 Year Old (bourbon, $19.99)

    Sigh – another one whose price has skyrocketed in the past few years. I remember buying Elijah Craig for just $11.99 in 2002 – in New York City, even! Now it’s very hard to find under $20, though still not overpriced if you like its idiosyncratic flavor. Elijah Craig shares with many of its fellow Heaven Hill bourbons a minty overtone that I often like (but occasionally loathe). Your mileage will also vary, but at this price the risk is low.

    With Elijah Craig 12 Year Old you also get some nice oaky tastes uncommon in younger, less expensive bourbons. The distillery that used to make Elijah Craig burned down some years ago, so the current bottlings come from a different distillery (owned by the same company, using the same recipe and warehouses). Of course various Internet conspiracy theorists and curmudgeons claim the older stuff was better, but I’ve no idea how to tell from the label which distillery a particular bottle came from. Anyway, it doesn’t matter. Beautiful bottle and cork stopper (the only whiskey on this page I would recommend giving as a gift), distinctive taste, still nicely- though not super-bargainly-priced.

Don’t forget, you can click these images to get a better sense of what each label or bottle looks like.

And a few runners-up in the category:

  • Old Grand-Dad Bonded Bourbon (bourbon, $19.99)

    An unabashedly rye-heavy bourbon made by Jim Beam. Old Grand-Dad Bonded (like all bonded bourbons, this is 100 proof) tastes wonderful to me – full of grain, confident in its old-school personality. But the texture is just a little too thin for it to make my top list in this price range. The Old Grand-Dad 114 is much richer on the palate (and comes in a fancier bottle), but sells for 25% more.

  • Bulleit Bourbon Frontier Whiskey (bourbon, $21.99)

    Diageo’s answer to Beam’s Knob Creek brand. I much prefer Bulleit to its hipster competitor. Though the (excellent) packaging implies this is a rough-and-tumble whiskey, it’s actually quite gentle. Floral, with lots of the fruit that I associate with rye-heavy bourbons. Listed as a runner-up only because I can’t find it consistently under $20 (sometimes dips to ~$18 in California when there’s a mega-sale on).

  • Jim Beam Rye (rye, $14.99)

    With its former bright yellow label and super-low price, Jim Beam Rye was the sort of thing you might skip over at the corner bodega. But you would have been wrong – in its day this stuff was downright great. Meaty, sizzling, in your face (in a good way). Unfortunately this whiskey seems to have fallen on hard times in recent years. Even before Beam switched to the gentler beige label shown here, I tasted several bottles that were too young. Lots of banana esters and other immature unpleasantness, though with an overall reticence unbecoming of this former muscleman. Still, if you’re on a dark street corner and the shady liquor shop has Jim Beam Rye, then it’s worth taking a chance on.

  • Old Overholt Straight Rye Whiskey (rye, $14.99)

    Another Jim Beam product, Old Overholt seems pretty much synonymous with rye whiskey in every bar. It is absolutely fine for a Manhattan or Old Fashioned – preferable to even high-end bourbons in those particular drinks. I’ve tried it neat only a couple of times, but found the finish too quick. So while I wouldn’t recommend it on its own, you shouldn’t hesitate to try it as the base of your cocktails.

(Side note: earlier in 2009, John Hansell of Malt Advocate started a couple of good conversations about whiskey prices and high-value whiskies on his blog here and here.)

My blog includes posts on all sorts of unrelated topics. You can find just the whisky posts here.

4 Comments

  1. Greg J

    I know Rittenhouse 100 Rye and Old Grand Dad well, and Bulleit and Jim Beam a big less, and an a fan of all. I’m always impressed when Old Grand Dad is the well bourbon at a dive bar — def way above the quality bar I expect for $2 a shot, but I find it as the house pour at many spots in SF. Nice collection, EEP.

    Posted on 15-Dec-09 at 10:05 pm | Permalink
  2. @Greg J: I think Old Grand-Dad comes in several bottling strengths. I suspect the recipes are the same (though the Bonded is required to come from the same year, so might have some more flavor variation). I bet those bars are pouring 80 or 86 proof OG as their well bourbon. Still probably good stuff – just that I haven’t had it alongside the 100 proof Bonded or 114 proof to compare.

    Posted on 15-Dec-09 at 10:34 pm | Permalink
  3. bjorn

    this is truly god’s work eep. just bought several bottles of the very old barton from binny’s. looked at the other selections at binny’s and their prices aren’t very reasonable. i’ll have to find the others locally but with shipping it is still reasonable it it is indeed hard to find..

    now that buffalo trace is 19.99 at my local, it looks like it is going to be a very bourbon 2010.

    Posted on 16-Dec-09 at 12:17 pm | Permalink
  4. @bjorn Yep, I really like Brett Pontoni, the spirits buyer at Binny’s. Really nice guy, good palate, customer-focused, and gets lots of cool exclusive bottlings.

    And it *used* to be that it was cheaper to order from them and have it shipped than to buy at shops in California – especially since you pay nearly 10% extra for tax when you buy locally. But no more – often cheaper in California these days. I’ve been surprised to see how quickly and how high Binny’s prices have risen in recent years.

    Posted on 16-Dec-09 at 12:21 pm | Permalink

3 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. [...] a nice cocktail from Death’s Door White Whiskey, but given the alternatives – even those costing half as much – you wouldn’t want to make this your late-evening contemplative [...]

  2. [...] Favorite Budget Bourbons, by Ethan Prater [...]

  3. [...] of the day. A great base beer aged in a barrel formerly holding my favorite rye (see my post here). “Sensational. Chocolate, hints of coffee, some sweet, some dry, some wood. Full of flavor, [...]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *
*
*


Warning: Unknown: open(/home/content/74/5445474/tmp/sess_6lu3rtg6kn53l6ad99atda5rv0, O_RDWR) failed: No such file or directory (2) in Unknown on line 0

Warning: Unknown: Failed to write session data (files). Please verify that the current setting of session.save_path is correct () in Unknown on line 0